Index  ›  legal  ›  BBC
legal · BBC ↗

Airline fined after man loses leg in Heathrow accident

BBC Published Jun 4, 2010 Reviewed Jul 2, 2026 ✓ Reviewed by citations.press editors
Airline fined after man loses leg in Heathrow accident
American Airlines was ordered to pay more than £80,000.
more than 80000 pounds · , court
American Airlines was fined £70,000 and ordered to pay £10,581 costs.
70000 pounds ·10581 pounds ·
American Airlines was ordered to pay more than £80,000 in fines and costs after a ground worker lost his leg in a 2008 Heathrow accident.
more than 80000 GBP · fines and costs
Ground worker Kulwant Bhara, aged 45, had his right leg amputated below the knee after being run over by a 70-tonne aircraft towing vehicle at Heathrow in 2008.
45 years · Kulwant Bhara70 tonnes · aircraft towing vehicle (tug)
American Airlines had only three aircraft towing vehicles at Heathrow, and modifying them with audible alarms and reversing lights would have taken seven hours and cost £1,000.
3 · aircraft towing vehicles (tugs) at Heathrow7 hours · modification time1000 GBP · modification cost
Judge Nicholas Loraine-Smith noted that two similar accidents had occurred in the US and stated it was regrettable that American Airlines in London knew nothing about them.
2 · similar accidents in the US Judge Nicholas Loraine-Smith, Judge
American Airlines was fined £70,000 and ordered to pay £10,581 in legal costs.
70000 GBP · fine10581 GBP · legal costs
A safety review in May 2007 failed to consider the significant risk of someone being struck by the aircraft towing vehicle.
2 · missed opportunities to address deficiencies (including May 2007 safety review)
Kulwant Bhara was run over by a 70-tonne vehicle.
, court
Bhara had his right leg amputated below the knee after the accident in 2008.
American Airlines had just three such vehicles at Heathrow.
3 ·
Modifications would have taken seven hours and cost £1,000.
7 hours ·1000 pounds ·
there had been two similar accidents in the US.
2 ·
safety review in May 2007.

A court has criticised an airline after an accident at Heathrow airport caused an employee to lose a leg.

American Airlines was ordered to pay more than £80,000 after ground worker Kulwant Bhara, 45, was run over by a 70-tonne vehicle used to move aircraft.

Mr Bhara, from Slough, had his right leg amputated below the knee after the accident in 2008.

The company, which admitted two health and safety charges, said it had since brought in changes and retraining.

The court heard it was dark when the accident happened and the aircraft towing vehicle, known as a "tug", had no audible alarm for reversing or specific reversing lights.

Judge Nicholas Loraine-Smith said at the Old Bailey: "These two factors contributed significantly and it should have had both."

American Airlines had just three such vehicles at Heathrow and the modifications would have taken seven hours and cost £1,000, the court heard.

"These deficiencies should have been addressed long before this accident and two opportunities to do so were missed back in 2007," said the judge.

He noted that there had been two similar accidents in the US and said: "It is regrettable that American Airlines in London knew nothing about these incidents."

In addition there was a safety review in May 2007 which "for reasons it is difficult to understand did not consider the significant risk of someone being struck by the vehicle", the judge added.

"That failure to recognise that risk at this stage led to this accident."

American Airlines was fined £70,000 and ordered to pay £10,581 costs.

The company said in a statement: "American Airlines has always openly accepted its responsibility in this incident and consequently has co-operated fully with investigations by the Health and Safety Executive which brought the case.

"The airline has also conducted its own internal investigation to establish the causes that led to this sad accident and to learn any lessons that will prevent anything similar happening again in the future.

"This investigation did identify procedural areas which could be improved and American has since implemented all changes to this effect, including equipment upgrades and the re-training of staff."

This article was originally published by BBC ↗. citations.press indexes the source-backed facts above and links to the original. Something wrong? Corrections policy · Report an error