Index  ›  legal  ›  NY Post
legal · NY Post ↗

Boy, 13, died after falling from carnival ride with missing seat restraints: lawsuit

NY Post Published Aug 19, 2026 Reviewed Aug 20, 2026 ✓ Reviewed by citations.press editors
Boy, 13, died after falling from carnival ride with missing seat restraints: lawsuit
Clayton Phillips died after falling from the 'Yo-Yo' carnival ride in Butte, Montana, in June 2024.
1 · Clayton Phillips Clayton’s estate, plaintiff
The lawsuit alleges that at least 10 chairs of the 'Yo-Yo' ride had deficiencies, including missing restraint components.
at least 10 · chairs of the 'Yo-Yo' ride Clayton’s estate, plaintiff
Shady Acres Safety Services inspected the 'Yo-Yo' ride at least twice in the month before the incident.
at least 2 · inspections by Shady Acres Shady Acres Safety Services, company
The lawsuit seeks punitive damages from the city-county government of Butte-Silver Bow, Midway West Amusements, Shady Acres Safety Services, owner Dennis Sutherland, and 20 yet-to-be-identified persons or entities.
20 · persons or entities Clayton’s estate, plaintiff

See more of our coverage in your search results.

A 13-year-old boy died after he fell off a “Yo-Yo” carnival ride while it was going full speed, after carnival workers allegedly signed off on safety inspections despite several seats missing restraints, according to a new lawsuit.

Clayton Phillips died two weeks after he was flung from the moving ride in Butte, Montana, back in June.

Clayton’s estate alleges that at least 10 of the chairs of the “Yo-Yo” ride had deficiencies — including missing restraint components — which were “visible and readily discoverable,” according to the lawsuit, obtained by NBC Montana

However, it is believed improperly trained employees allegedly allowed Clayton to sit in a chair without the proper restraints — and/or the restraint system failed to keep him locked in, according to the outlet.

The family is seeking punitive damages from the city-county government of Butte-Silver Bow, Midway West Amusements, ride inspection company Shady Acres Safety Services, Shady Acres Safety Services owner Dennis Sutherland, and 20 yet-to-be-identified “persons or entities responsible for the inspection, maintenance, assembly, supervision, management, loading, or operation of the Yo-Yo ride or carnival.”

Clayton fell from the ride while it was going full speed in the Butte Civic Center parking lot on Sunday, June 7, for an annual pop-up carnival event.

Michelle Jensen, the owner of Midway West claimed after the horrific accident that the only precaution taken by operators was to tell riders not to use the broken seats, according to the lawsuit filed in Butte-Silver Bow District Court last week.. 

She allegedly admitted problems with the ride to police and said replacement parts were ordered, the filing claims. 

Shady Acres allegedly inspected the ride at least twice in the month before the incident — and Sutherland signed off on the inspections, which concluded there were no serious issues, according to the complaint.

The government of Butte-Silver Bow was responsible for the premises and had authority to “reasonably inspect the carnival premises and the passenger-loading areas of the rides,” the suit claims.

Clayton’s family is seeking “all compensatory, general, special, economic, and noneconomic damages recoverable by the Estate,” the cost of the victim’s suffering, lost earnings, funeral expenses, recoverable costs of the emergency and medical response, and more, the outlet reported.

This article was originally published by NY Post ↗. citations.press indexes the source-backed facts above and links to the original. Something wrong? Corrections policy · Report an error